Skip to content
MiltonFriedman.org

Milton Friedman on Paternalism and consumer protection

On the first half of the question, I believe that there is a case for keeping certain things out of the market. I believe it’s not desirable to have a market in atomic bombs. But the number and the list of things for which you can really justify prohibition is very limited. And the only justification is always in terms of the existence of innocent victims, not in terms of paternalistic concern.

Context. From the questions after his keynote address at the Fifth International Conference on Drug Policy Reform, in Washington, D.C., on November 16, 1991. Arnold S. Trebach asked, in the first half of a two-part question, “Should every produced good be subject to the free market?”

The Drug War as a Socialist Enterprise
Speech, 1991, Questions and answers after his keynote address at the Fifth International Conference on Drug Policy Reform, Washington, D.C., November 16, 1991; adapted as Ch. 7 of Friedman & Szasz on Liberty and Drugs, ed. Arnold S. Trebach and Kevin B. Zeese (Drug Policy Foundation Press, 1992), p. 58
Checked against the sourceFind the book

Where this comes from

Checked against the sourceThe wording was checked against the work itself.

Cite this passage

Milton Friedman, “The Drug War as a Socialist Enterprise” (1991), Questions and answers after his keynote address at the Fifth International Conference on Drug Policy Reform, Washington, D.C., November 16, 1991; adapted as Ch. 7 of Friedman & Szasz on Liberty and Drugs, ed. Arnold S. Trebach and Kevin B. Zeese (Drug Policy Foundation Press, 1992), p. 58. https://miltonfriedman.org/quotes/only-justification-for-prohibition-innocent-victims-not-paternalistic-1991

Quoted for commentary and research. Rights in the underlying work remain with its rights holder, so cite the work itself, not only this page.

Topics

He also said

  1. The major effect of drug prohibition is to multiply the number of innocent victims, not to reduce them.

    Context. From the questions after his keynote address at the Fifth International Conference on Drug Policy Reform, in Washington, D.C., on November 16, 1991. Asked by Arnold S. Trebach whether every produced good should be subject to the free market, he has said that there is a case for keeping certain things, such as atomic bombs, out of the market, but that the list of things whose prohibition can really be justified is very limited, and that the only justification is always the existence of innocent victims, not paternalistic concern.

    The Drug War as a Socialist Enterprise
    Speech, 1991, Questions and answers after his keynote address at the Fifth International Conference on Drug Policy Reform, Washington, D.C., November 16, 1991; adapted as Ch. 7 of Friedman & Szasz on Liberty and Drugs, ed. Arnold S. Trebach and Kevin B. Zeese (Drug Policy Foundation Press, 1992), p. 58
    Checked against the sourceFind the book
  2. But I have to admit that the one negative feature of legalizing drugs is that there might be some additional drug addicts. However, I want to qualify that in still another way. The child who’s shot in a slum in a pass-by shooting, in a random shooting, is an innocent victim in every respect of the term. The person who decides to take drugs for himself is not an innocent victim. He has chosen himself to be a victim. And I must say I have very much less sympathy for him. I do not think it is moral to impose heavy costs on other people to protect people from their own choices.

    Context. From a television interview about the war on drugs. Just before, Friedman says the evidence on whether legalization raises drug use is very mixed: when Alaska legalized marijuana, its use among high school students went down, and in Holland, which does not prosecute soft drugs, use by young people has gone down too.

    America’s Drug Forum interview
    Interview, 1991, With Randy Paige, taped at the International Conference on Drug Policy Reform, Washington, November 1991; reprinted as Ch. 8 “On Liberty and Drugs” in Friedman & Szasz on Liberty and Drugs, ed. Arnold S. Trebach and Kevin B. Zeese (Drug Policy Foundation Press, 1992), pp. 69–70
    Checked against the sourceFind the book
  3. There is no chance whatsoever in the near future or the distant future of getting what I would really like, which is a free market. As a first step on the right road, I believe the right thing to do is to treat drugs, currently illegal drugs, exactly the same way you treat alcohol and tobacco. Not because that’s the best way, not because that’s the ideal arrangement, but because it’s an arrangement that people know, that is in existence. It involves, in a certain sense, the least kind of change, so that the law you’ve described by Senator Galiber seems to me the right direction in which to go—right direction in the sense again of a practical compromise, not of ultimate principle.

    Context. From the questions after his keynote address at the Fifth International Conference on Drug Policy Reform, in Washington, D.C., on November 16, 1991; his answer to the last question. Arnold S. Trebach asked what he thought of suggestions for how a retail market in re-legalized drugs should be modeled: Lester Grinspoon of Harvard had suggested a harmfulness tax based on the relative harmfulness of the drugs, and Senator Galiber of the New York State Senate had put in a bill that would have made all the illegal drugs available legally but regulated them like alcohol (for example, only adults could get them, and no retail store could be near a school).

    The Drug War as a Socialist Enterprise
    Speech, 1991, Questions and answers after his keynote address at the Fifth International Conference on Drug Policy Reform, Washington, D.C., November 16, 1991; adapted as Ch. 7 of Friedman & Szasz on Liberty and Drugs, ed. Arnold S. Trebach and Kevin B. Zeese (Drug Policy Foundation Press, 1992), p. 64
    Checked against the sourceFind the book

Think this quote is wrong, misattributed, or missing context? Report it and it gets fixed, not argued with.